Prior to submitting my item for consideration, I obtained appraisals from three different locations and researched the reviews that were listed for WP Diamonds. Written in a review, WP Diamonds responded to a customer that they provide offers that are "50-70%" of Blue Nile diamond jewelers. As such, I took my lowest appraisal (along with my GIA appraisals) and researched what Blue Nile would charge for my diamonds, as well as several other wholesale companies. I figured, eh, low, but I get it. When the representative called, he started with, "Well, reviewed your appraisal and we do not agree with their assessment." I was like ok, I get it. Then they gave me the price. I could only laugh and hang up. I am sure WP Diamond will write some rebuttal, and I do not care. I understand they are a business and must make a profit. However, it is not for me to provide them with a months payroll of profit. I would advise to only sell your jewelry to this company if you are absolutely desperate. Do not believe the trolls they must have set up to provide all those positive reviews. Update: As expected your rebuttal arrived. I understand you have to justify your offer, and I can even follow your argument. However, they were already sold to a company for more than three times your low offer. I should take advantage of your, "if someone offers you more, we will pay you," but that would require that I contact your company again... and I am sure you have some further loop-hope to not pay. Cheers!